The South Carolina Supreme Court just weighed in on the S.C. Payment of Wages Act (“PWA”), specifically the written notice requirement for reductions in pay and the applicable statute of limitations. In this case, the Court reviewed a jury verdict from 2022 where the jury had awarded over $500,000 in unpaid wages, which the trial judge tripled to nearly $1.6 million. I blogged about this case when the Court of Appeals issued its decision in Fall 2025. [Read more: Jury Awards $1.6 Million Verdict for Wage Theft in SC] At that point, the Court of Appeals had ruled the PWA allowed employees to sue when a company fails to provide the required seven days’ advance written notice of any reductions in pay; this is what lawyers call “a private right of action” for that specific violation. [Read more: Recovering Unpaid Wages in South Carolina]
Companies Must Still Provide Seven Days’ Advance Written Warning of Reductions in Pay
However, the Supreme Court overruled that holding. [Read the Court’s opinion here: Hess v. Morphis Pediatric Group] Instead, this week, the Court clarified that while companies did have to provide seven days’ advance written notice in accordance with S.C. Code 41-10-30 (A), a company’s failure to do so does not, in itself, create a private right for the employee to sue. An employee can still sue for a failure to pay the underlying wages, but a violation of the notice provision is subject only to an investigation by the S.C. Department of Labor, which can then issue a fine.
Practically speaking for the Plaintiff in this case, that particular ruling doesn’t change much, as the employee wasn’t arguing for a private right of action under the notice provision, but rather simply that the company’s failure to follow the statute’s requirements meant that the abrupt reduction in pay was not lawful and therefore did not go into effect. The company would still have to pay the employee what was already owed before the change took place.
The Statute of Limitations Begins When the Wages Are Due, Not When the Employee Discovers the Unpaid Amounts
The Court’s other holding does, however, impact the employee’s claims and the verdict. The Court also looked at the applicable statute of limitations. In this case, the bonuses that the employee claimed became due as early as 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015. The employee did not file his lawsuit until 2018. The PWA provides what we call a statute of limitations (SOL) of three years, meaning that an employee must file a lawsuit within three years of the wages being due. The employee argued that the “discovery rule” applied, meaning that the SOL is triggered when the employee learns about the unpaid wages. But the Court clarified that SOL begins to run exactly when the statute says it does: when the payment was due, not when the employee found out. With that ruling, the employee’s potential damages would be limited to only the 2015 bonus, cutting out the 2011-2014 bonuses. The Supreme Court has sent this case back to the trial court to make further determinations on the amounts that are owed. Potentially this could result in a retrial on the damages issue, or the judge may just adjust the amount owed. I’ll continue to follow the case to see what the trial court does. [Read more: Wage Theft in South Carolina and the SC Wage Payment Act]
Takeaways for South Carolina Employees
The Supreme Court’s clarification on the statute of limitations issue emphasizes the need for employees to act promptly when they learn about unpaid wages. That SOL begins ticking as soon as the company fails to pay you what you are owed, and the longer you delay, the more risky your case becomes.
The Court’s decision also clarifies that while employers must follow the notice requirements for reductions in pay, the proper avenue for enforcement is through a wage complaint to the SC Dept. of Labor. Dealing with LLR can be frustrating on my end, as their enforcement power is limited. But the PWA still provides employees with the right to sue their employers for unpaid wages, along with the right to recover tripled damages and attorney’s fees. [Read more: Treble Damages for SC Wage Payment Claims] An unpaid wages lawyer in South Carolina can review your claim and discuss your legal options.
If you are owed unpaid wages, commissions, or bonuses, feel free to contact Summerlin Law today at (864) 278-5389 or via our Contact Us page for a review of your legal situation.